Gregory Plot

Gregory Plot
Variables tas, rst, rlt
Models MPI-ESM1-2-LR, GISS-E2-1-G, IPSL-CM6A-LR, ACCESS-ESM1-5, EC-Earth3, CNRM-CM6-1, AWI-CM-1-1-MR, CNRM-ESM2-1, FGOALS-g3, INM-CM5-0, MRI-ESM2-0, ifs-fesom
Reference Dataset CERES_EBAF + ERA5
Units K
Period 1990–2014
Method Net TOA = TOA net SW + TOA net LW. Obs uses CERES EBAF for TOA + ERA5 for T2m.

Global Mean Radiation Budget

Global Mean Radiation Budget
Variables rst, rlt, rstcs, rltcs, rss, rls, rsscs, rlscs, rsds, rlds, tas
Models ifs-fesom, CERES, CMIP6 MMM
Reference Dataset CERES_EBAF
Units W/m2
Period 1990–2014

Radiation Imbalance Time Series

Radiation Imbalance Time Series
Variables rst, rlt
Models ifs-fesom, CERES, CMIP6 MMM
Reference Dataset CERES_EBAF
Units W/m2
Period 1990–2014

Surface Net Radiation Annual Bias

Surface Net Radiation Annual Bias
Variables rst, rlt, rstcs, rltcs, rss, rls, rsscs, rlscs, rsds, rlds, tas
Models ifs-fesom, CMIP6 MMM
Reference Dataset CERES_EBAF
Units W/m2
Period 1990–2014
ifs-fesom Global Mean Bias: -6.06 · Rmse: 11.19
CMIP6 MMM Global Mean Bias: -3.08

Surface Net Longwave Annual Bias

Surface Net Longwave Annual Bias
Variables rst, rlt, rstcs, rltcs, rss, rls, rsscs, rlscs, rsds, rlds, tas
Models ifs-fesom, CMIP6 MMM
Reference Dataset CERES_EBAF
Units W/m2
Period 1990–2014
ifs-fesom Global Mean Bias: -4.42 · Rmse: 7.95
CMIP6 MMM Global Mean Bias: -5.72

Surface Net Shortwave Annual Bias

Surface Net Shortwave Annual Bias
Variables rst, rlt, rstcs, rltcs, rss, rls, rsscs, rlscs, rsds, rlds, tas
Models ifs-fesom, CMIP6 MMM
Reference Dataset CERES_EBAF
Units W/m2
Period 1990–2014
ifs-fesom Global Mean Bias: -1.64 · Rmse: 10.87
CMIP6 MMM Global Mean Bias: 2.64

TOA CRE Longwave Annual Bias

TOA CRE Longwave Annual Bias
Variables rst, rlt, rstcs, rltcs, rss, rls, rsscs, rlscs, rsds, rlds, tas
Models ifs-fesom
Reference Dataset CERES_EBAF
Units W/m2
Period 1990–2014
ifs-fesom Global Mean Bias: -3.04 · Rmse: 6.26

TOA CRE Shortwave Annual Bias

TOA CRE Shortwave Annual Bias
Variables rst, rlt, rstcs, rltcs, rss, rls, rsscs, rlscs, rsds, rlds, tas
Models ifs-fesom
Reference Dataset CERES_EBAF
Units W/m2
Period 1990–2014
ifs-fesom Global Mean Bias: 0.14 · Rmse: 9.78

TOA Net Radiation Annual Bias

TOA Net Radiation Annual Bias
Variables rst, rlt, rstcs, rltcs, rss, rls, rsscs, rlscs, rsds, rlds, tas
Models ifs-fesom, CMIP6 MMM
Reference Dataset CERES_EBAF
Units W/m2
Period 1990–2014
ifs-fesom Global Mean Bias: -0.38 · Rmse: 7.78
CMIP6 MMM Global Mean Bias: 0.58